William Katz: Urgent Agenda
|
||
|
SNIPPETS, our daily collection of short items and comments, is here. --------------------------------------------- Our next subscription drive will be in October. However, readers are invited to subscribe at any time. Subscriptions are voluntary, but are critical to keeping us going. Subscribe in the right-hand column. -------------------------------------------- Answers to last week's "Current Question" are here. The new "Current Question" is here, in the right-hand column. --------------------------------------------
SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 14, 2008
Now look at the Obama states, in blue. Every one of them is a mountain for McCain, some, like California and New York, unclimbable. Once solid-GOP N ew England is now solid for the Dems. There may be a shot in Colorado, and another in Minnesota, although I'd doubt the latter. Even Michigan may come into play, but it would take a huge effort. New Hampshire is a very-much outside shot, as is Pennsylvania. So, no overconfidence. This is a fight to the finish, and must be waged every day, without mistakes. It can be done, but we're not there yet.
This is the new politics of Barack Obama? Sounds like the old politics of the Chicago machine. UPDATE AT 5:56 P.M. ET: Senator Claire McCaskill, Democrat of Missouri, went after John McCain on ABC's "This Week" today over age and cancer:
Real class. I want a written guarantee from the Obama campaign that Obama will survive the next four years. I want that certified. I want that notarized. Then we'll discuss McCain's health. Yuch.
TRUTH Posted at 2:42 p.m. ET Dems are having a field day today quoting Karl Rove as saying the McCain campaign is stretching the truth. Trouble is, in saying it, they're stretching the truth. From The Politico::
The exact transcript of Rove's remarks, spoken on Fox:
Now, Team McCain, get in front of this story. Correct any misstatements, explain others that were misunderstood, then demand - giving a list of particulars - that the Obama side do the same. The McCain campaign has, as I've written, gotten sloppy with facts. The Obama campaign simply ignores them. McCain can turn this negative into a positive. September 14, 2008. Permalink
TRACKERS Posted at 1:37 p.m. ET Both our standard trackers are now out, and both show exactly the same result as yesterday. Rasmussen - McCain up three. Gallup - McCain up two. The Hotline tracker has not yet been published. We're now 10 days out from the GOP convention, and McCain's lead, although small, still holds. The press attempts to destroy Palin, lead by The New York Times, haven't worked, but the McCain campaign must be on guard against foolish mistakes, exaggerations or misstatements that feed the Palin-hating beast. (Palin said that Alaska provides 20 percent of the nation's energy. That turns out to be way off, but she may have meant it in a different context. Once challenged, she's got to explain. Don't leave questions out there.) While the momentum was with McCain coming out of his convention, that momentum has now stopped, and we're settling into the familiar pattern of a close race, although now it's McCain holding the edge. This can still go either way, and an unpredictable event can throw out all current figures. September 14, 2008. Permalink
COMMENT: If Minnesota is in serious play, Obama is in serious trouble. It means he'll have to devote resources in the state that should have gone elsewhere. But let's be cautious and see what Minnesota polls say in coming weeks. UPDATE AT 9:42 A.M. ET: First tracker of the day is out. Rasmussen reports that, for the third day running, McCain is up three. The race stands at 50-47. Two thirds of the polling for today was conducted after Charlie Gibson's first interview with Sarah Palin aired. There apparently was no damage, at least not in this poll.
THE WHY Posted at 8:25 a.m. ET The general consensus among political writers is that McCain is slightly ahead. The Politico has looked at the situation and provided five reasons why. I think this is a reasonable, if tentative analysis. A week is a lifetime in politics, and things can change:
McCain as change agent.
The center shifts. Independents move to McCain.
The economic gap narrows.
Palin narrows the enthusiasm gap.
Democrat voter ID edge dulls.
What is significant, I think, is that all this is happening during the most relentless press assault on a candidate I've seen since the assault on Barry Goldwater in 1964. The continuing attack on Sarah Palin either isn't working, or is creating a backlash. McCain's gains can, of course, be reversed. But there's an old political saying that you can't beat somebody with nobody, and Barack Obama is quickly turning into a nobody. The novelty has worn off, his attacks on McCain have taken on a desperate quality, and many of his allies among the bloggers, journalists and ladies of "The View" aren't doing him any good with their wild statements. One question is whether Sarah Palin's novelty will wear off as well. It might if she does more of these overly familiar sit-downs. And the McCain campaign must be careful. Its aggressiveness and daring have worked. But a certain sloppiness about facts and claims is creeping into its rhetoric. Eventually, the public may react if there are too many exaggerations or botched statistics. The press will not investigate Obama's claims and will not examine his background the way they've examined Palin's. There's no help available there. The McCain campaign has to be almost bulletproof to continue upward. September 14, 2008. Permalink
SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 13, 2008
A bocce tournament? So you missed the most important political interview of the season? Nance, you can record these things. They have machines, with buttons. Geez.
Two paragraphs later the story says this:
Which is it, guys? The story also points out that Palin used a teleprompter at a speech today. Boy, is that news. I don't know if I could have voted intelligently without knowing that. I think the public is smart enough to catch on. I hope so. September 13, 2008.
If toss-ups are thrown out, and turned into leaners, Obama/Biden wins with 273 EVs, to McCain/Palin's 265. As a general rule, Obama polls better than he delivers, and has tended to be a weak closer. However, we give the standard investment-industry caution that past experience is not a guarantee of future results. Incredibly close race.
GUYS FOR SARAH Posted at 8:01 p.m. ET The assumption is that Sarah Palin is attracting throngs of women to the GOP ticket. It turns out, though, that it may be men who are more attracted. The New York Daily News reports on some fascinating numbers:
It may be logical:
Whatever the logic, it's working:
Finally...
There is good news here, but there are also warning signs. Palin's newfound support can be peeled away, especially support in the middle, where elections are won and lost. The Obama side is now engaged in an all-out attack, and the press will help out. But Obama has been off his game recently, and his advisers seem baffled by Palin and her appeal. May their attack turn into surrender. September 13, 2008. Permalink
COMMENT: Please note the use of the word "sheltered." The patronizing tone here is beyond obvious. Bias? What bias?
BIAS? WHAT BIAS? Posted at 2:57 p.m. ET Reader Bill Palmer alerts us to the comparison between Charlie Gibson's interview with Barack Obama, and his interview with Sarah Palin. The comparison is stark. Ironically, the Hillary Clinton Forum published this list of the Obama questions:
And the Palin questions:
The transcript of the Gibson/Obama interview is here:
The transcript of the Gibson/Palin interview is here:
Bias? There's bias? Are you seeing things? September 13, 2008. Permalink
TRACKERS Posted at 1:54 p.m. ET Both our two standard trackers - Rasmussen and Gallup - are in for the day, as is the Hotline trackers. As reported below, Rasmussen reports a three point McCain lead, same as yesterday. Gallup reports a two-point McCain lead, a statistical tie. McCain was up five points only three days ago. Hotline reports a one-point McCain lead. Yesterday it had Obama up by one. So, averaging them, McCain is up by two. But this may be deceptive. Both Gallup and Hotline measure registered voters, Rasmussen measures likely voters. McCain tends to do somewhat better among likely voters. Traditionally, Republican voters are more likely to vote. So far the McCain convention bounce seems to be holding. We'll watch that this week. Also, these trackers are measuring only one night of surveys following Charlie Gibson's first interview with Sarah Palin. And they are not measuring Obama's new aggressiveness. Still, a very tight race. September 13, 2008. Permalink
SARAH Posted at 8:19 a.m. ET Sarah Palin will continue to be the story in coming days. She's doing another "exclusive" interview, this time with Sean Hannity of Fox. That will be written off in advance because Hannity is clearly a Palin partisan. Palin is entering a period of extreme danger. The press is determined to destroy her. It must destroy her. She's being asked questions that Barack Obama has never been asked, that no reporter seeking advancement in his profession would dare ask. I winced when Charlie Gibson, professorial glasses down over his nose, asked Palin if she'd ever met a foreign leader. Did Lincoln ever meet a foreign leader? How many foreign leaders did Bill Clinton meet before he became president? What a childish question. It's frustrating because Barack Obama was made chairman of a subcommittee of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. The subcommittee dealt with Europe. He never held one meeting. Nor did he make a single trip to the area under his authority. The only foreign leaders he could have met were the ones floating through Washington. In reality, Obama is a minor-league U.S. senator with a weak record, never thought of as a leader, who presumes to be president. No one in the mainstream media challenges his credentials. And can you name a single mainstream journalist who has gone back over Joe Biden's record and challenged his judgments? Joe Biden isn't even there. The extreme danger for Sarah Palin is that the novelty will wear off and the press will bear in. There is an investigation of her underway in Alaska that has suddenly been put on the fast track. You may be sure it will be treated as a major story, even though it is minor. She'll be portrayed as corrupt, there will be suggestions that she broke the law. To cite a line used by Republicans when Harry Truman fired Douglas MacArthur, "Impeachment was discussed." The word will come up. Destroy, destroy. What should she do? Well, the first thing she should do is limit these sit-downs. They can do her no good. I'd rate her first performance, with Gibson, a B-. Sarah should do a Reagan - limit press availability and speak over the heads of the media to the American people. That works for her, it's her brilliance. The press will whine, but no one will really care. Noel Coward, the British wit, songwriter and playwright, once said that there must be an invisible barrier between performer and audience. You may look, but you may not touch. The same is true in politics. Americans don't want their major figures to be household objects. They want them to be familiar and distant at the same time. The disgraceful Jimmy Carter carried his own bags when president. Americans hated it. Ronald Reagan wouldn't enter the Oval Office without wearing a jacket. Americans loved it. It is a balance. Reagan understood. FDR understood. Kennedy understood. The danger for Sarah is that the mystique can wear off if she becomes too familiar. When I worked on The Tonight Show, some famous performers turned down invitations to appear, citing that same factor - the fear that they would become too familiar, too close, that the aura would be destroyed. They were right. Let Sarah be Sarah. No, I don't want to see her on Oprah. I want to see her on the campaign trail, next to John McCain, and giving us the same magic we saw at the convention. And if journalists complain, I hope they complain as loudly as possible. The public will drown them out. September 13, 2008. Permalink
Posted at 8:15 a.m. ET The new Obama ad ridiculing John McCain because McCain doesn't use e-mail is turning out to be more of a blunder than we'd originally thought. At first it seemed just a bit snotty. Now it seems to be a personal, and ugly insult. Jonah Goldberg at NRO explains:
Obama serves with John McCain in the U.S. Senate. Didn't he ever know that? What precisely does Obama do in the Senate? Does he ever observe anything, except himself in a mirror? The McCain people should exploit this. No shame in doing it. Make Obama look like an insensitive dilettante. Why not tell the truth? Obama is now engaging in what he openly admits is a rougher campaign. The idea is to throw him off, portray him as a blunderer, an ordinary politician, and not the messianic figure sold to us earlier. September 13, 2008. Permalink
|
"What you see is news. What you know is background. What you feel is opinion."
SUBSCRIPTIONS: Subscriptions to URGENT AGENDA are voluntary. Why subscribe to something you're getting free? To help guarantee that you'll continue to get it at all. Subscriptions sustain us. Payments are through PayPal and are secure, but you do not have to sign up for a PayPal account. Credit cards are fine. FOR A ONE-YEAR ($48) SUBSCRIPTION, CLICK: FOR A SIX-MONTH ($26) SUBSCRIPTION, CLICK: IF YOU DON'T WISH A SET SUBSCRIPTION, BUT PREFER TO DONATE ANY OTHER AMOUNT TO SUSTAIN URGENT AGENDA, CLICK:
POWER LINE: It's a privilege for me to post periodic pieces at Power Line. To go to Power Line, click here. To link to my Power Line pieces, go here.
THE CURRENT QUESTION Last week we asked, What are the three most absurd positions put forward by Barack Obama? You can view the answers here.
This question was was suggested by reader Francis Drouillard: What will Obama supporters do if he loses? If you'd like to send us your thoughts, click:
CONTACT: YOU CAN E-MAIL US, AS FOLLOWS: If you have wonderful things to say about this site, if it makes you a better person, please click: If you have a general comment on anything you see here, or on anything else that's topical, please click:
FAVORITE SITES (List will grow) Power Line
|